Cowboy Money

Foundations · 3 min read

Courthouse Steps

In Texas, foreclosures sell on the first Tuesday.

The first Tuesday of every month, on the courthouse steps, in the open air, like something out of a black and white movie. It isn’t a movie. It’s still how it works. And one morning in the spring of 2009 I stood on the steps of the courthouse in my hometown and watched them sell the Lyric.

The Lyric was the old theater on the square. Brick and terra cotta, built in 1926, with a marquee that had gone dark sometime in the eighties and a ceiling inside painted to look like a sky at dusk. I’d snuck in there as a kid through a loose door in the alley, just to lie on the floor of the balcony and look up. It’s the reason I became an architect. I’m not being poetic. It’s the actual reason.

A man named Dale Whitlock had bought it a few years earlier with big plans. Restaurants, lofts, the marquee lit again. Dale was not lazy and Dale was not foolish. Dale was one of the sharpest people I’d ever met.

What Dale did was what all the sharp people were doing then. Property went up every year, so he borrowed against the Lyric to buy the building next to it. Then he borrowed against both to buy two more around the square. Every year the buildings were worth more, so every year it made sense, right up until the year it didn’t. The crash came. The lending dried up. Values fell through the floor, the bank wanted its money all at once, and Dale didn’t have it.

He hadn’t bet a little. He’d bet everything, on the idea that the weather only moves in one direction.

My dad had a line for that. He said it over the phone that night when I told him.

There’s being wrong and there’s being finished. You can survive the first a hundred times. You only get the second once.

Dad said Dale’s mistake wasn’t borrowing. Everybody borrows. Dale’s mistake was borrowing so that being wrong didn’t cost him something. It cost him everything.

Dale came that morning. I didn’t expect him to. He stood off to the side of the steps in a pressed shirt with his hands in his pockets, and when the trustee read out the legal description of the Lyric in a flat, bored voice, as if it were a used appliance, Dale didn’t move. Two investors from out of town bid it up a little. One of them won. The whole thing took eleven minutes. I timed it, because I didn’t know what else to do with my hands.

Afterward Dale walked over and shook mine.

“Somebody ought to fix that ceiling,” he said. That was all.

I’ve thought a lot about the people who survived that year. They weren’t smarter than Dale. Most of them simply borrowed less. They left themselves room to be wrong, and when the room came due, they had it.

I’d like to tell you I learned it that morning. I didn’t. Ten years later a good friend asked me to go in with him on a restaurant, and I put in more than I could afford to lose. That’s a different story, and I paid full price for it.

But I learned it eventually. And when I did, Dale’s face was the one I saw.

He’s fine, for what it’s worth. He works for a bank now, of all places, and he’s good at it. He tells young borrowers about the first Tuesday. I hear they don’t listen either.

The Lyric sat empty for six more years. Then the investors who bought it called a small restoration studio to see about the ceiling. My studio. I spent most of a year on a scaffold forty feet up, repainting a sky at dusk.

These days, before I put anything real on the table, I picture those courthouse steps and ask myself one question. If I’m wrong about this, am I wrong, or am I finished?

Wrong, I can live with. Finished is the one to stay away from.